Sea Of Tranquility

The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu

Manning: Charlestown

The beautiful Dean-esque cover art, reminiscent of Yes's "Fragile", should leave you under no illusions: you are sailing to the land of Progressive Rock!

Sailing, in the context of this brilliant new album from Manning, is a very appropriate word, as the 35-minute title track tells the tale of a perilous cargo journey along the English coast during the 18th century.

Emboldened by the success of his band at RosFest, Guy Manning has produced one of the bravest and most stunning pieces of music that has graced the rock world for some time. Progressive rock it may be, but it is a genre-busting composition courtesy of the lightness and symphonic complexity that Manning has built into the piece. Eschewing the trend of his peers, which is tending to heavier music in the (elusive?) search for larger audiences, he has produced a timeless, classic piece in the greatest traditions of English maritime music-making. Don't get me wrong this is a progressive rock piece for sure, and it does "rock out" when the story-telling dictates it. There are also folk and classical elements: Manning's band includes a violinist, cellist, saxophonist and flautist and these textures, as well as modern keyboards, bring great beauty, depth and subtlety to the composition. The orchestration is superb. There are wonderful moments of melodic beauty. This sea-faring adventure is recounted just as well through the music indeed, some sections are purely instrumental as through the lyrics.

The composition is constructed in several seamless sections, as the stages of its journey develop: the ship meets both wreckers who attempt to run the ship aground and steal the cargo and storms before, having suffered significant loss of life, it finally arrives at its destination. One of the strengths of the composition is how the instrumental textures are able to evoke various images of the sea and the journey; in this way Charlestown continues a great tradition in English music-making through the ages. Of course, such an English sea-faring theme treated at such length demands that there will be elements of folk music within the composition and they are there, well integrated. Throughout, Manning's ear for melody is sharp and he delivers some great ones, none more so than the beautiful melody at the denouement of the story, releasing the tension in classic fashion. It makes your hairs stand on end, it is so beautiful.

"Charlestown", on its own, is worth the price of this CD several times over.

In order to create such beautiful music, Manning are not a small band: there are seven band members and three guests appearing on Charlestown. Composer Guy Manning plays acoustic, 12-string and classical guitars, keyboards, electric guitars, mandolin, bouzouki, bass and percussion, as well as being the lead vocalist and adding harmonies. Busy man! Joining him in the band are: Kris Hudson-Lee (bass), Kevin Currie (electric guitars and backing vocals), David Albone (drums, percussion), Chris Cattling (electric guitars and backing vocals), Julie King (backing vocals) and Stephen Dundon (flutes). Adding those additional musical textures are: Ian "Walter" Fairbairn (violin), Kathy Hampson (cello) and Alison Diamond (soprano and tenor saxes).

But back to the album....

Of course, following up such a composition on the album is difficult, given its brilliance and the emotional investment the listener has made in the piece; virtually anything that follows is likely to break that spell. However, Manning do succeed remarkably well in doing this: "Caliban and Ariel" has the requisite lightness and grace, as well as instrumental textures to make it an excellent choice as the follow-up piece. Its catchy chorus keeps the listener in Manning's web.

"The Man in the Mirror" keeps a similar feel going and again delivers a very catchy chorus, as well as a folky, Fairport Convention-like break towards the end. The Hammond playing on this is delightful. It's the catchiest song on the album, in days gone by it an edited version may well have been a hit single. "Clocks", with its beautiful flute, maintains the musical cohesion and, once more, Manning delivers a very catchy melody for the chorus.

These three tracks follow "Charlestown" about as perfectly as one could wish for, maintaining a satisfactory musical synergy. However, the last two tracks, whilst very good in themselves, depart from that cohesive album "feel" that has been established. "T.I.C" is rockier and is infused with a gentle waft of blues. The instrumental final track, "Finale", despite its thematic links back to "Charlestown" motifs, has a jazzy vibe that departs from the musical feel of the opener. What happens as you listen to these final two numbers is that the magic bubble of "Charlestown" is popped and you re-enter the real world; the realisation dawning that you have experienced something rather special.

The issue of album dynamics is insufficient to dock any rating points from what is surely one of the albums, if not the album of the year. Time will tell.

Track Listing:-
1) Charlestown (35:10)
2) Caliban and Ariel (2:58)
3) The Man in the Mirror (6:26)
4) Clocks (4:28)
5) T.I.C. (5:14)
6) Finale (7:17)

Added: January 6th 2011
Reviewer: Alex Torres
Related Link: Manning's MySpace
Hits: 3852
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]


[ Back to the Reviews Index | Post Comment ]

» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews:

Manning: Charlestown
Posted by Steven Reid, SoT Staff Writer on 2011-01-05 15:21:27
My Score:

Come with me on a voyage across stormy seas where the perils are many and the rewards great. That's what Guy Manning is asking you to do with his wonderful Charlestown album, which is bold enough to begin with a thirty five minute epic (from which the album takes its name), that is superbly paced, both in terms of having a genuinely interesting and involving concept and the instrumentation which is allowed to ebb and flow through the stormy waters in a manner that brings an unhurried and poised elegance to proceedings. The story covers tail ships sailing during 1700 and 1800's with goods and cargo around the perilous seas that surround the English coast. That may not sound exactly riveting, but the subject matter is perfect for the atmospheric, sometimes brash, often subtle, but never less than engrossing music that it is surrounded by.

There's no doubt that with such a weighty opener that we are deep into progressive territory, but to Manning's credit, the band use that lengthy time to bring an evolution to the song that has it altering and maturing through a variety of styles and vibes. The use of saxophones and cello, violin and flute broadens the pallet of colours on display in a track that evokes everyone from Yes to Fairport Convention, or Jethro Tull to ELP and a whole lot more besides. The whole song is built on a deeply set percussive groove that builds the roots from which all the instruments sprout and blossom through the folky, jazzy, progressive mix, over which the vocals of Guy himself dance lightly, without ever breaking the spell the music creates. The only word that really adequately describes all of this is stunning. Simply stunning. This is progressive music as it should be, considered and skilfully planned, but loose and flowing in execution to the extent that if it wasn't obvious by how all the passages, moods and vibes knit together that this has been toiled over for a considerable time, you could believe that some of it was jammed in the studio.

So how do you follow an epic song that verges on being a masterpiece? Well the answer is not easily and so it ever so slightly proves. Now before I go on, let me say that if the five songs on this disc had made up an entirely separate album, I would be raving about it, however after the glorious sea faring tale they follow, none of the subsequent songs quite live up to their lengthier sibling. Don't be put off though, as the standard remains remarkably high through the short, piano and strings based "Caliban And Ariel" and the slowly building folk burst of "The Man In The Mirror". "Clocks" continues that vibe, with strings and flute taking the main melody lines in a wonderfully restrained song that resists the temptation to ever really up the tempo, before "T.I.C." brings another glorious groove into view, with flute and sax this time vying for supremacy. "Finale" sets our course back into the same vibe as the title track of the album and benefits from the same poise and pacing that makes "Charlestown" the stunning work that it is. It bookends the album very well, but I can't help but wonder if possibly having this track follow straight on from the opening song and maybe even having the other five songs on a second disc wouldn't have improved the flow of an already fantastic set. Either way, that is nit-picking and shouldn't in any way deter anyone who loves progressive rock from buying what is a wonderful album.

2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by