Sea Of Tranquility

The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu

Celestial Oeuvre: This Mortal Coil

The fabulously named Celestial Oeuvre are a self-styled neo-progressive band from NYC playing, on the basis of This Mortal Coil, an exciting brand of Yes-derived rock, with elements from ELP. There will be other influences in there, but they were the main sonic elements that stood out: if you deduce from this that the keyboards play an essential and exciting, fast-tempo part, then you'd be right. Starcastle are another name that comes to mind for the "listening post", for those of you who use comparisons to decide whether or not to check out a new band.

As a result of the influences and compositional style, this might not be the most original album you've heard, but the execution is very good and therefore the music appealing. Good melody, good rhythm, good pace, good musicians, good composition an album you can't go wrong with really! This Mortal Coil is the band's second album after 2004's independently released Second Chance: it's an album that does full justice both to Unicorn's faith in the band as well as to their statement that it is their "labor of love". Jose Damien (all keyboards, bass, guitar) and Joe Acaba (vocals) form the compositional team and are therefore the backbone and soul of the band, which is completed by Joe Nardulli (lead guitars) and Hector Lopez (drums, percussion, bells & whistles).

"The Meadows" kicks off the album in fine style at pace, the keyboards to the fore, alternating with Nardulli's meaty guitar. It's a fine sound and sets the tone for the album! The "Family Secrets" trio cements the album's qualities, Nardulli and Damien trading breaks and Acaba putting in a fine vocal performance. The music can be quieter and more ethereal too, such as on the opening to "This Mortal Coil", where the melodic control and the harmonies are both excellent before the song "opens up" to rock. "Melody Makers" has a catchy riff and would make a good single. "Encore" is that rare beast an excellent rock instrumental. "Sold Out" has more delightful melodies and instrumental turns - and the album continues in strong fashion until virtually the end.

"In Ivory Dreams", the album's major opus and the song in effective "anchor" position, for me doesn't succeed as well as the previous ones; it's almost as if the band was trying too hard to create a "major opus". Perhaps it's an issue with the songs' running order, rather than the song itself; I felt the album needed a "kick" at this stage to really ram home its quality; instead the pace is slow throughout and the melody not sufficiently pretty to compensate. The a capella finish of "The Meadows" didn't really wow me either; it's not the way I would have chosen to end what is otherwise an excellent album.

These last couple of issues shouldn't cloud the overall quality of the album. Certainly the band has produced enough quality music over its duration to justify the adequacy of its own compositions and of the specific choices they've made. Therefore I concede that these issues that I've raised are more about personal choices of mine rather than actual criticisms of the music or of the album; nevertheless, they are perhaps a reflection that the album, whilst very good, is unlikely to be one of those "world-beaters" that everybody likes.

However, if you've ever enjoyed Yes, ELP, Starcastle or similar bands, then I can recommend This Mortal Coil without hesitation.

Incidentally, the art-work is fab!

Track Listing:-
1) The Meadows (6:45)
2) Family Secrets prologue (3:07)
3) Family Secrets (4:45)
4) Family Secrets epilogue (0:10)
5) Unwind This Mortal Coil (5:26)
6) Melody Makers (4:41)
7) Encore (to the Melody Makers) (2:11)
8) Sold Out (5:39)
9) A False Utopia (4:18)
10) Cool Burn (4:07)
11) In Ivory Dreams (7:16)
12) The Meadows (reprise a capella) (0:43)

Added: January 19th 2010
Reviewer: Alex Torres
Related Link: Band's Website
Hits: 3287
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]


[ Back to the Reviews Index | Post Comment ]

» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews:

Celestial Oeuvre: This Mortal Coil
Posted by Jon Neudorf, SoT Staff Writer on 2010-01-19 22:51:59
My Score:

Celestial Oeuvre are another one of those bands that have slipped through my radar having not heard any of their output until their most recent release This Mortal Coil. The band, found on the Unicorn Digital label, was formed in 2004 by Joe Acaba (vocals) and Jose Damien (keyboards, bass, guitar) and are joined by Joe Nardulli (acoustic and electric lead guitar) and Hector Lopez (drums, percussion, bells, whistles).

The first time I spun This Mortal Coil it did not really grab me. However, as is often the case with music, I needed a couple more spins before this album finally began to click. One aspect of the band that did not sit right at first were Acaba's vocals but I am not sure why as they are truly excellent. He has a strong and powerful voice and is able to show restraint but can really hit those high notes when called upon. After the vocals clicked everything else began to fall into place. Good guitar solos with some heavier riffs, fantastic keyboards, in particular organ which harkens back to 70s hard rock bands like Deep Purple, and a solid rhythm section. This is heavy progressive rock with a definite retro feel.

"The Meadows" gets the ball rolling with some nice guitar crunch and organ riffs paying homage to Deep Purple. The vocals are in the higher register and are very well done and the vocal arrangement is excellent as it is in many of these songs. At times the vocals had me thinking of Shadow Gallery, not that they sound like that band but can be similarly complex. "Family Secrets" is a three part suite that reminded me greatly of 80s period Yes especially the vocals and keyboards. Elements of Pink Floyd also crop up, in particular the atmospheric instrumental section with dreamy electric guitar and lush keyboards.

My favourite song so far is the highly accessible "Unwind This Mortal Coil" with an absolutely killer melody. Acaba's vocals are stellar and the guitar and keys become more dramatic as the song gets a little heavier. The ear catching "In Ivory Dreams" is another winner with a fine melody, beautiful vocals, acoustic rhythms and subtle synths bubbling just below the surface. Recent Yes would again be a good comparison. The album ends with "The Meadows" a short a cappella number with an intricate vocal arrangement.

The bottom line: if you like 80s and 90s Yes, great vocals and highly accessible progressive rock, This Mortal Coil warrants further investigation. I really enjoyed it.

(originally reviewed for

2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by