Sea Of Tranquility



The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu




Metamorphosis: I’m Not A Hero

Five years on from their The Turning Point album - which in itself was the band’s first effort for some seven years - Swiss neo-progsters Metamorphosis return proclaiming I’m Not A Hero. With such a layoff, maybe it’s not a surprise that the band’s configuration has changed, a five piece now slimming down to three as singer JP Schenk adds keyboards to his duties and guitarist Olivier Guenat proves that he’s a master of four strings as well as six. With drummer Alain Widmer still firmly in place, this streamlined trio sound no less confident as they mine an attack that’s served many a nineties into noughties band well, with the likes of Galahad, Arena and IQ brought to mind as this album wends its way through its nine tracks. However, while those comparisons can often flit into and out of mind as this disc spins, it does so in a much more patient setting, with nearly all of I’m Not A Hero residing in a mid-paced, contained situation. It’s an approach that especially works with the calm vocals from Schenk, as he embellishes his own keyboard contributions with a really sympathetic ear.

As you journey from the likes of “Little Stars Desintigrate” (their spelling, not mine) through “More Is Less” and onto “Leftovers”, what’s clear is that guitarist Guenat is more than capable of providing a little fire in terms of his solos and the occasional biting riff. To me it’s an aspect of the Metamorphosis sound that feels underused and while the synth work is of the highest order, to have such a talented guitarist often sidelined into adding sprinkled clean guitar-lines hits as something of a missed opportunity, even if his (still slightly restrained) soloing in both of the latter named songs verges on phenomenal in terms of touch and tone.

Now, that may all sound a little negative but in reality I’m Not A Hero is an atmospheric journey and approached as such, makes quite a hefty impact. Arguably the framework on which nearly everything hangs lacks for just a little variance but the instrumentation is superb and there’s no doubt that this band have a clear intent regarding what they want to do. The gyrating riffage at the opening of “So Now What” arguably suggests what might just happen if that blueprint was less strictly adhered to, but in the end this album is still a solid, interesting foray into the world of neo-prog.


Track Listing
1. Dark World
2. I'm Not a Hero
3. Little Stars Desintegrate
4. When Life Starts Again
5. More Is Less
6. I Will Leave Tonight
7. Leftovers
8. So Now What
9. So Hard's the Road

Added: September 25th 2021
Reviewer: Steven Reid
Score:
Related Link: Progressive Promotions Records
Hits: 1070
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]

  

[ Back to the Reviews Index | Post Comment ]

» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews:

Metamorphosis: I’m Not A Hero
Posted by Eric Porter, SoT Staff Writer on 2021-09-25 15:25:00
My Score:

Leader and keyboardist Jean-Pierre Schenk has been the only constant member of Metamorphosis in the bands 20 year history. Schenk is the chief songwriter and vocalist, and admits to a heavy Pink Floyd influence, citing the later Gilmour lead years specifically. The opening “Dark World” starts off with brooding atmospheric keyboards, there is a metallic undertone courtesy of the guitars and a nod to Brian May with the layered harmonies in some of the solo breaks. There is a nice build up at the songs conclusion. The title track offers up more atmospheric keyboards, and a vocal that reminds me of Blackstar era David Bowie, but even at this point in the CD, they are stuck in plodding and uninteresting tempos. Guitarist Olivier Guenat suddenly jumps out of the mix, with a wild solo, that while impressive, feels out of place. As “Little Stars Desintegrate” opens, it’s clear the band needs a producer to assist with the arrangements. The songs are more suited to 4 -5 minute range; the music is too repetitive to maintain interest over the 6-7 minute lengths. Guenat displays his chops in the instrumental “When Life Starts Again”, but the song meanders, and does not feel focused. He pops his head out during “More or Less” and “Leftovers, these are the moments where my ears perk up, but it’s not enough to stay interested. Schenk’s voice is serviceable, but lacks a powerful delivery; the addition of a strong lead vocalist would be an improvement. To be honest, it was difficult to get through the last 3 or 4 songs, it just sounded like more of the same. The musicianship is good, but the best analogy I can provide is Metamorphosis is like a plane heading down the runway, but never gets airborne; the music just never takes off.



2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by SpeedSoft.com