Sea Of Tranquility

The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu

Circle II Circle: The Middle of Nowhere

Zak Stevens left Savatage in 2000 in order to take a little break from music and then make a comeback with his own band. I was excited to hear Circle II Circle's debut album Watching in Silence, because Zak has always been one of my favourite singers of all times. Watching in Silence proved to be a very Savatage-like record from songwriting to sound to production to instrumentation. I always thought since it was Zak's first album as a solo artist, the second album would have a more original sound and style. However, shortly after the debut was released, all members except Zak left the band (only to team up with Jon Oliva on his Tage Mahal album) and Zak had to seek new bandmates. Needless to say, this has reflected on Circle II Circle's sophomore disc, The Middle of Nowhere.

The new album certainly tries to steer away from the classic Savatage sound, but at the same time, it retains certain characteristics and musical ideas. This comes as no surprise, as once again eight out of ten songs on the album were co-written by Savatage members Jon Oliva and Chris Caffery. Zak only penned two songs ("In This Life" and "Lost") with Angel Dust axeman Bernd Aufferman. Given the statistics, it is inevitable not to sound like Savatage when you receive so much input from others. Sometimes I think Zak should have never left Savatage, since CIIC obviously functions as an extension of his former band. On this album, according to the liner notes in the booklet, Zak had more control over how things should be done. He produced the whole album by himself and mixed it with Jim Morris. Unfortunately, the production isn't up to par with his debut album or the Sava releases done by Paul O'Neill. One thing that I noticed is the mastering of the album is weak, especially in between tracks. The frequency level of the sounds is a bit annoying when you try to listen to the album on headphones.

The sound, overall, is raw and more in your face. Because there is little to no keyboards or piano on the album, the guitars are way up in the mix. Paul M. Stewart's bass performance is probably the best thing on the album; it's present in every song and very powerful, unlike the debut release. Zak's voice sounds kind of different too. Maybe it's because he wanted to go for a more raw-sounding album, but gone are his crystal clear vocals that we have come to expect from him. This album finds him doing some really gritty vocals; it doesn't sound bad, but then it doesn't sound quite like Zak Stevens either. I don't want to put this album down, but vocal-wise, this will probably be my least favourite Zak Stevens release. There are no counterpoint vocals, not enough soaring vocal harmonies like the ones on "Forgiven" or "Watching in Silence", and certainly not enough piano melodies accompanied by killer guitar runs. The only exception is the title track, as it starts with nice piano work played over really heavy guitar riffs. Towards the end of the song there is a nice counterpoint harmony that is perhaps the most amazing moment on the album.

The songs are generally heavier and faster than the ones on the debut. Like I already said, the bass is fantastic, be it on "All That Remains", "Cynical Ride" or the power-ballad "Faces in the Dark". Andy Lee and Evan Christopher play lots of rhythm-based melodies with occasional guitar solos. It has to be noted though that the solos on this disc pale in comparison to Matt LaPorte's stuff on the debut. Still, you'll hear good melodies on "Open Season", a track that greatly reminds me of Blaze - could it be because of CIIC's extensive tour with him last summer? The solo on "Cynical Ride" is also amazing. Other than that I think the closing piece "Lost" is a nice acoustic track. "Psycho Motor", on the other hand, is perhaps the worst song Zak has ever done. Its hard rock vibe, weak chorus and loose mix simply don't go well with Zak's musical background.

Bottom line, The Middle of Nowhere is a very good melodic metal release judging by its own merits. However, compared to Zak's earlier efforts, it simply lacks the aestheticism, complex arrangements over spacious production and multi-textured piano melodies woven into searing guitar solos present on Watching in Silence. It's by no means a weak album, just not good enough by Zak's standards.

Track Listing
1) In This Life
2) All That Remains
3) Open Season
4) Holding On
5) Cynical Ride
6) Hollow
7) Psycho Motor
8) Faces in the Dark
9) The Middle of Nowhere
10) Lost

Added: September 20th 2005
Reviewer: Murat Batmaz
Related Link: Circle II Circle Website
Hits: 4239
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]


[ Back to the Reviews Index ]

» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews:

Circle II Circle: The Middle of Nowhere
Posted by Pete Pardo, SoT Staff Writer on 2005-09-20 07:02:01
My Score:

The latest release from former Savatage singer ZachStevens is a raw and in your face collection of melodic hard rock and metal tunes. While not the instant classic that was the Circle II Circle debut Watching in Silence, The Middle of Nowhere certainly has its moments, like the catchy rumble of "Cynical Ride" (which sound a little like 80's Kiss), the Savatage-like "Hollow", and the atmospheric and moody rocker "Faces in the Dark". However, there are a few tunes that sound sort of beneath what Stevens is capable of, notably the generic "Psycho Motor" , and the use of silly nu-metal type compressed vocals on "Holding On".

Don't let those two songs sway you though, as The Middle of Nowhere still contains plenty of strong vocals, crunchy guitar riffs & hot leads, and memorable melodies. Many will notice that much of the symphonic keyboard parts that were so prevalent on Watching in Silence are non-existent here, and even though most of the tracks were co-written by former Savatage mates Jon Oliva and Chris Caffery, I think Zak wanted to get a different sound on this record, and he certainly did. It's just that the album doesn't quite measure up to the debut, but any time you get a new album from Mr. Stevens it's certainly a good thing.

2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by