Sea Of Tranquility

The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu

Steve Hogarth | Richard Barbieri: Not The Weapon But The Hand

The Marillion and Porcupine Tree camps have in recent years spawned a rather impressive amount of extracurricular projects, with Transatlantic, Kino, DeeExpus, Blackfield, and OSI, among others all making some increasingly intricate and impressive music. However back in 1997 Marillion singer Steve Hogarth teamed up with Porcupine Tree synth wizard Richard Barbieri, for the vocalists first and so far only solo album Ice Cream Genius. On the whole that release was Marillion-lite, with a Pop vibe dominating the odd Art-Rock element, making for a fun, if unessential listen. Since then the pair have frequently spoken about working together again, although it has taken fifteen years for the fruits of their labours to result in an album's worth of material - and one which is almost as far removed from their previous collaboration as it possibly could be.

Pleasingly different from Marillion and P-Tree, Not The Weapon But The Hand is a dark, eerie exploration of moods, textures and atmospheres that relies more on creating expansive washes of sound, than it does conventional songs. Progressive could be one way to describe it, but synth led Art-Rock may well be closer to the mark. Far from being instant, NTWBTH is a real grower of an album, with a crystal clear and at times intentionally unnerving sound being beautiful, expansive, yet somehow claustrophobic and oppressive at the same time. Hogarth thrives in this sparse, moody setting, with his voice being a beacon of light, if not always hope, in the gloom - an effect that is doubled when he contrasts his stunning vocals with an evocative narrative style which he uses to speak many of the lyrics.

Sliding beautifully from song to song, this is an album that demands to be listened to in its entirety, with the mood created ebbing, flowing and building as the music progresses. Album opener "Red Kite" sets the tone in stunningly patient style, with its seven minutes never getting beyond a gentle, ambient shimmer as gentle synth themes are punctuated by Hogarth's vocals and whispers. The theme is continued into "A Cat With Seven Souls", which challenges through its beat and harsh arrangement and "Naked" which is ever so slightly more forceful and starkly melodic. "Crack" does exactly that, juddering you out of the sleepy dreamy atmosphere with a force that is made all the more stark by what it follows. Ambient, almost dancy beats are punctuated by manic vocal bursts, counterpointing with lush layers of voice, while "Your Beautiful Face" again flourishes through its sparseness, making the beautiful, building string infused chorus of "Only Love Will Make You Free" almost painful in contrast. "Lifting The Lid" adds the merest hint of crawling jazz, something beautifully contradicted by the short yet stunning title track which brings the atmosphere right back to where we started.

This is the end of the physical version of the album; however the deluxe download version does offer the extra song "Intergalactic" which closes things out on a serious, yet Electro-Poppy note. In an age where record companies are keen to exploit their buying public with bonus tracks, limited versions and tour editions, it is also gratifying to know that this final track, which was a late addition to the album was actually sent out for free to those who had previously pre-ordered the Not The Weapon But The Hand from Marillion's Racket Records store. Well done to all involved!

Even with the hugely impressive catalogue that Hogarth and Barbieri have amassed over the years, I have no hesitation in suggesting that Not The Weapon But The Hand is one of the best albums that either has ever been involved with. Quite stunning...

Track Listing
1. Red Kite
2. A Cat With Seven Souls
3. Naked
4. Crack
5. Your Beautiful Face
6. Only Love Will Make You Free
7. Lifting The Lid
8. Not The Weapon But The Hand
9. Intergalactic (download version only)

Added: March 19th 2012
Reviewer: Steven Reid
Related Link: Not The Weapon But The Hand online
Hits: 3992
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]


[ Back to the Reviews Index | Post Comment ]

2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by