Sea Of Tranquility

The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu

For All We Know: For All We Know

Despite the unfortunate tendency for many progressive rock "supergroups" to pale in comparison to the individual members' day jobs, the debut effort from For All We Know offers a top-notch album from some of the business's finest musicians. A stunning observation that stands as one of the genre's finest offerings in the last decade-plus, this eye-opening effort should truly send shockwaves through progressive rock and metal fans worldwide. Although 2011 may be a bit of a slow year when it comes to strikingly original and unique progressive metal albums, this debut stands as a shining example that prog metal can still be done correctly over twenty-five years into its history. Did somebody say "masterpiece"?

Though this is essentially a side project from Within Temptation's Ruud Jolie, he recruits a star-studded cast consisting of Wudstik (Ayreon) on vocals, Kristoffer Gildenlöw (Dial, Pain of Salvation) on bass, Leo Margarit (Pain of Salvation) on drums, Thijs Schrijnemakers (Stereo) on Hammond organ, and Marco Kuypers (Cloudmachine) on piano and Rhodes. As if that's not an impressive enough lineup already, guest vocalists include Daniel Gildenlöw (Pain of Salvation), Sharon den Adel (Within Temptation), Damian Wilson (Threshold, Ayreon), Ruud Houweling (Cloudmachine), Anke Derks, and Tom Sikkers (Daybroke), and guest musicians John Wesley, Richie Faulkner, and Camilla van der Kooij also contribute. One glance at a list like that, and it's clear that For All We Know consists of brilliant musicians - and they certainly don't disappoint either. The musicianship, while never crossing the line into extremely technical territory, remains tasteful and impressive throughout the album's entire duration.

In spite of Ruud Jolie's symphonic metal background, the music here is a stark contrast to his work in Within Temptation. I'd describe For All We Know as a crossing point between Pain of Salvation, Hogarth-era Marillion, Porcupine Tree, Riverside, and Wolverine. That means you should expect mellow progressive metal that's focused heavily on atmosphere and melancholy, rather than technicality and heaviness. There are actually quite a few times where I'd hesitate in even calling For All We Know a metal album - some excellently placed heavy riffs reaffirm that this album is certainly prog metal, but many softer tracks like "Keep Breathing" and "Nothing More" make the album ride the border between prog rock and prog metal. The fresh, unique sound that Ruud Jolie successfully captures makes For All We Know stand out immediately in the fairly stagnant modern prog metal genre.

From a songwriting standpoint, For All We Know tremendously exceeds any of my preconceived expectations. Every song here is its own unique journey, each one standing terrifically on its own, yet even better when pieced together as a full experience. That is my key expectation when we're talking about musical masterpieces, and For All We Know offers some of the most stunning and emotional progressive metal compositions I've ever heard. I reckon it impossible to listen to a track like "Down On My Knees", "Open Your Eyes", or "Nothing More" without goosebumps running up your arms and legs. This is some of the most beautiful music I've ever heard played by some of the most passionate musicians in the industry... there's certainly not much more I could ask for.

In case I haven't praised For All We Know enough (which, trust me, I haven't), the warm and powerful production deserves a mention. Although extremely polished and modern, it maintains a highly clean and captivating sound that makes the album even more appealing. I can't think of any production that would better suit the music here.

I really don't think there's much else to say. For All We Know is a stunning album by a stunning group that I honest-to-god hope makes more albums before calling it quits. It'd be quite a shame to see such a fantastic project end after just one album. But even if that is the case, the band has graciously left us with one of the finest progressive metal albums ever created... and that's ultimately what matters most. This album holds a special place in my collection, and I'm sure it'll be cherished for many years to come. I would not let this essential masterpiece slip through your fingers, and anyone who enjoys progressive rock/metal should get this one in their CD player as soon as possible. In a place called "utopia" every album would be this moving, but as that is not the case, we must cherish the few truly outstanding albums that grace our ears - and For All We Know is surely one of them. Of course, 5 stars are the least I can give in this scenario. For All We Know may very well have claimed album of the year with their terrific debut.

Track Listing:
1. Blind Me
2. Busy Being Somebody Else
3. Out of Reach
4. When Angels Refuse to Fly
5. I Lost Myself Today
6. Keep Breathing
7. Down on My Knees
8. Save Us…
9. Embrace/Erase/Replace/Embrace
10. Tired and Ashamed
11. Open Your Eyes
12. Nothing More…

Added: August 13th 2011
Reviewer: Jeff B
Related Link: For All We Know Website
Hits: 3915
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]


[ Back to the Reviews Index ]

» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews:

For All We Know: For All We Know
Posted by Steven Reid, SoT Staff Writer on 2015-12-26 09:44:57
My Score:

For All We Know is a side project from Within Temptation guitarist Ruud Jolie that has slowly but surely built up over the past four years into a full band. A quick look at the guest list for the album – Damian Wilson (Threshold), John Wesley (Fish/Porcupine Tree (live)) and Ruud Houweling (Cloudmachine) will give the game away that Jolie has crafted twelve songs worth of progressive rock that on occasion stray into metal, but then with a band name like For All We Know, what else could they be??

Taken out of the Within Temptation framework Jolie has revealed a darker more melancholy side to his music and has to be said that the end results are decidedly impressive. Yes there are similarities to the likes of Porcupine Tree, Riverside and Pain Of Salvation, but the sharp, well crafted themes and deep dark atmospherics sound reassuringly solid and avoid being contrived copies. In fact, so solid are the performances on this album that For All We Know easily withstands comparisons to any other band in this genre and with vocalist Wudstik (Ayreon) adding a more commercial edge to the songs, they are actually slightly more accessible than a lot of the leaders in this musical area. The rest of the band are no slouches either, with Kristoffer Gildenlöw providing fretless bass and Leo Margarit manning the drums (both Pain Of Salvation), alongside Marco Kuypers (Cloudmachine) on piano, Rhodes and harmonium and Thijs Schrijnemakers (Stereo) adding Hammond organ. Impressive though that list may be, it would count for nothing if the music didn't cut the mustard, but with songs like "I Lost Myself Today", which swats round a beautiful piano melody and string arrangement and the deeply dark, yet beautifully melodic strains of "Tired And Ashamed", there was never any danger of that happening. The quality really doesn't dip throughout the whole album, but the longest song on show "Keep Breathing" is the best illustration of what For All We Know are capable of. The guest singers all add their weight to this song, but it is the more direct and pacey riff that brings things so stunningly into focus. The song begins with a joyous burst of guitar that slowly builds into the most overtly progressive passage on the disc, before meandering into a beautifully constructed solo that sings over a slow melancholy backing. Then Boom! We are back into a catchy, commercial chorus again that could belong in many a chart bound rock song. Not content with that, a plaintive piano motif that is once more boosted by swirling strings helps close the song out. All of the elements of this song can be found woven throughout this album, but to be fair, most of the other songs use their shorter length to remain more focused and less diverse, which actually makes for a more cohesive and less self indulgent end result.

With the current rave reviews for the latest Within Temptation album and also some very favourable media coverage for Jolie's other side project Maiden uniteD, it really seems like the man can do no wrong right now and with For All That We Know he may well have just topped the lot!

© 2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content © Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by