Sea Of Tranquility



The Web Source for Progressive Rock, Progressive Metal & Jazz-Fusion
  Search   in       
Main Menu

Google Ads




Marillion: Live from Cadogen Hall (Blu-Ray)

The first official Blu-Ray from Marillion is a live document recorded at the very end of their acoustic Less Is More tour in December 2009. Whilst the band have flirted with the acoustic format across the Hogarth era at various fan club and one-off performances this was the first time they had based an entire project around these arrangements. The album itself was something of a surprise in that there were a number of less obvious choices ("Hard As Love", "If My Heart Were A Ball", "Quartz) but by the time of the subsequent tour acoustic staples such as "Easter" and "Beautiful" were included in the second half.

Overall this is a fine representation of the band in subdued live performance mode the first half was a run through of the album in its entirety before a more slightly upbeat second half where there are sprightly renditions of "Gazpacho" and "The Answering Machine" which get the crowd up and moving. Whether or not you thought this simply represents Marillion treading water until the next studio album proper is something of a moot point but by reinventing part of the back catalogue into such unique arrangements this was certainly not a project the band took lightly. The Blu Ray release adds a host of extras such as alternate versions of "Go!", "See It Like A Baby", Racket Television snippets and the Less Is More studio album itself is an audio extra. The whole show is presented in HD and , as with all things Marillion, there is a real sense of professionalism about the whole package.


Track Listing
Disc 1:
1. Go!
2. Interior Lulu
3. Out Of This World
4. Wrapped Up In Time
5. The Space
6.Hard As Love
7. Quartz
8. If My Heart Were A Ball
9. It's Not Your Fault
10. Memory Of Water
11. This Is The 21st Century
Disc 2:
1. No One Can
2. Beautiful
3. This Train Is My Life
4. You're Gone
5. 80 Days
6. Gazpacho
7. The Answering Machine
8. Estonia
9. Easter
10. Three Minute Boy

Added: October 24th 2011
Reviewer: Dean Pedley
Score:
Related Link: Band Website
Hits: 2095
Language: english

[ Printer Friendly Page Printer Friendly Page ]
[ Send to a Friend Send to a Friend ]

  

[ Back to the Reviews Index | Post Comment ]

» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews:

Marillion: Live from Cadogen Hall (Blu-Ray)
Posted by Jordan Blum, SoT Staff Writer on 2011-10-24 06:29:05
My Score:

Like most legendary progressive rock bands, Marillion's career is often looked at as split into different chapters. Essentially, there's the original, more "prog" Fish era and the newer, more "radio friendly" Steve Hogarth era. However, unlike 70s pioneers Yes and Genesis (and more like current great Spock's Beard), Marillion was still able to maintain great songwriting and lovely arrangements while leaning toward a more streamlined sound. Their recent DVD, Live At Cadogan Hall, is an excellent representation and celebration of their second phase.

While each viewer will have his or her own favorite songs, I enjoyed the immediately catchy and affective melodies of tracks like "This Train is My Life" and "Memory of Water" the most. Steve Hogarth is a phenomenally singer; he conveys a fragility few other vocalists can match. As for the rest of the band, they do an excellent job of reworking the songs into more acoustic and earthly arrangements. Best of all, Hogarth provides humorous banter and touching storytelling between just about every song. Overall, it's easy to see how Marillion still possesses humility as they perform each song with passion and delicacy. There's also a sense of intimacy as the band performs on a relatively small stage in front of a relatively small (yet extremely appreciative) audience. On Live At Cadogan Hall, Marillion prove to still be going strong.


Marillion: Live from Cadogen Hall (Blu-Ray)
Posted by Ken Pierce, SoT Staff Writer on 2011-03-21 09:31:03
My Score:

************This is a review of the DVD release of Live from Cadogen Hall************

I recently absorbed the new live CD release from Progressive Rock's own Marillion entitled "Live At Cadogan Hall" and as luck would have it, there is a companion DVD of this very show to enjoy as well and since I've said my piece on the audio only version it's now the videos turn for a little scrutiny. If you missed those words somehow and are one of those fans of Marillion who has been with them from the beginning, I essentially outlined my own personal confusion with what they are doing musically every now and again. I cited loving "Marbles" but hating its follow up "Somewhere Else" and then finding absolute disinterest in their acoustic offering "Less Is More". Of course on the same token, the live DVD for "Somewhere Else" totally impressed me and found me appreciating the studio effort a little more. That being said, this film finds us joining the band on the final night of their 2009 "Less Is More" tour where they perform for a packed house at London's Cadogan Hall. The film is presented in exactly the same fashion as its audio counterpart which I appreciated and that means it's broken into two sets and discs. The songs are delivered in the same manner and in a slightly Dream Theater method the guys perform "Less Is More" from beginning to end with the exception of the original albums closer "Cannibal Surf Babe". The audience seems hypnotized as Hogarth entertains with his rich and powerful vocal register and amuses all with his skills on dulcimer. As noted on the CD version review and as we found on the studio album, the band employed a number of instruments that they didn't normally use on a release for this one. I found hearing them play vibraphone and xylophone along with acoustic guitars and pianos to be quite the treat. Speaking on a musical level, it is without question that guitarist Steve Rothery, bassist Pete Trewavas, keyboardist Mark Kelly and Drummer Ian Mosely are superb musicians and their tightness and understanding of each others capability is almost visible during the show. I guess this comes from their working together for over 20 years at this point in this configuration.

The concert is very enjoyable to watch and especially for me since I didn't get to see any of the shows that catered to this format. The first half is a little more under stated as it presents you the full album "Less Is More". The audience sits transfixed by the band and there are times that you feel if a coin dropped that it would resonate across the hall like a shattering glass. Fortunately no cell phones go off as I think we would have witnessed an assault on the person. Highlights for me from the first set were "Quartz", "This Is The 21st Century" and "Its Not Your Fault", the latter of which was the sole new song presented to fans on the "Less Is More" CD. At the close of this part of the show, the singer announces their return after about twenty minutes and then they kick it into gear with ten more selections from their catalog done in a similar fashion to the "Less Is More" idea. For the second set we find the band beginning with the understated "No One Can" and "Beautiful" which are excellent but as the set continues on the band is livelier and their audience is responding in kind. There is more clapping in unison as H conducts them like an additional instrument and the speed and groove of the songs is kicked up a notch or three. The energy delivered by the band in this set will have you clapping along while you watch from the comforts of home. As it closed up I had to say that I was impressed and based on the stellar camera work and high definition recording that they did can safely advise you that this is a sound purchase. If you were one of those people who found the studio rendition of this stuff a little tedious I must admit that the live presentation made it all work. Marillion continues to surprise and confuse their fans but many stick by them no matter what. I was very happy to find them releasing this on Eagle Rock Entertainment since it should allow their musical message to reach an even wider audience than ever before.




2004 Sea Of Tranquility
For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility

SoT is Hosted by SpeedSoft.com